Thursday, October 01, 2020

Tips for Teachers: Developing Instructional Materials about American Indians

 Editors Note: This post was created as a one-page document that would fit into a single page. It is also available as a pdf. If you have trouble opening or downloading the pdf, write to us directly (see the "Contact" tab for Debbie's email address). A one-pager was hard to do! We wanted to add resources for each of the ten points. Instead, we'll be adding resources in the comments section. We encourage you to share the link to this post and the pdf with others but do not insert Tips for Teachers in something you are selling! We created this as a free resource. If you see someone selling it, please let us know. 


Tips for Teachers: Developing Instructional Materials about American Indians

Prepared by Debbie Reese (Nambé Owingeh) and Jean Mendoza (White) 

American Indians in Children’s Literature 


As educators develop or adapt lesson plans to teach about Native peoples, we recommend attention to the following:

(1) “American Indian” and “Native American” are broad terms that describe the Native Nations of peoples who have lived on North America for thousands of years. Recently, “Indigenous” has come into use, too (note: always use a capital letter for Indigenous). Many people use the three terms interchangeably but educationally, best practice is to teach about and use the name of a specific Native Nation.

(2) There are over 500 sovereign Native Nations that have treaty or legal agreements with the United States. Like any sovereign nation in the world, they have systems of government with unique ways of selecting leaders, determining who their citizens are (also called tribal members), and exercising jurisdiction over their lands. That political status distinguishes Native peoples from other minority or underrepresented groups in the United States. Native peoples have cultures (this includes unique languages, stories, religions, etc.) specific to who they are, but their most important attribute is sovereignty. Best practice—educationally—is to begin with the sovereignty of Native Nations and then delve into unique cultural attributes (languages, religions, etc.)

(3) There is a tendency to talk, speak, and write about Native peoples in the past tense, as if they no longer exist. You can help change that misconception by using present tense verbs in your lesson plans, and in your verbal instruction when you are teaching about Native peoples. 

(4) Another tendency is to treat Native creation and traditional stories like folklore or as writing prompts, or to use elements within them as the basis for art activities. Those stories are of religious significance to Native peoples and should be respected in the same ways that people respect Bible stories. 

(5) In many school districts, instruction and stories about Native peoples are limited to Columbus Day or November (Native American month) or Thanksgiving. Native peoples are Native all year long and information about them should be included year-round. 

(6) Native peoples of the 500+ sovereign nations have unique languages. A common mistake is to think that “papoose” is the Native word for baby and that “squaw” is the word for woman. In fact, each nation has its own word for baby and woman, and some words—like squaw—are considered derogatory. We also have unique clothing. Some use feathered headdresses; some do not.  

(7) To interrupt common misconceptions, develop instructional materials that focus on a specific nation—ideally—one in the area of the school where you teach. Look for that nation’s website and share it with your students. Teach them to view these websites as primary sources. Instead of starting instruction in the past, start with the present day concerns of that nation.

(8) To gain an understanding of issues that are of importance to Native peoples, read Native news media like Indian Country Today, Indianz, and listen to radio programs like “Native America Calling.”

(9) The National Congress of American Indians has free resources online that can help you become more knowledgeable. An especially helpful one is Tribal Nations and the United States: An Introduction, available here: http://www.ncai.org/about-tribes.

(10) Share what you learn with your fellow teachers! 

__________________________________________________________

Prepared on October 1, 2020. May be shared with others.
© American Indians in Children's Literature. 


7 comments:

Jean Mendoza said...

If you're a teacher looking for examples of lesson plans that are in line with these suggestions, AND that align with standards, see the ones created by Dr. Natalie Martinez to complement An Indigenous Peoples' History of the United States for Young People. They include

Origin Narrative: Thanksgiving
History of Indigenous Peoples' Day
Indigenous Perseverance: Wampanoag Survival 400 Years After the Mayflower.

Here's the page; you'll have to scroll down to find links: https://iph4yp.blogspot.com/p/the-teachers-guide.html

Debbie Reese said...

We also want to recommend the resources provided by the Smithsonian's National Museum of the American Indian. Their "Knowledge 360" is an excellent project.

Here's the resources page: https://americanindian.si.edu/nk360/lessons-resources/instructional

You can enter info in search fields. I chose "Diné" in the nation tab and found four resources, including a downloadable lesson plan about dolls: https://americanindian.si.edu/sites/1/files/pdf/education/SiYC_Dolls.pdf

Dennis Rowen said...

I just wanted to reminisce about Debbie from years ago. I designed an integrated literacy + content + technology unit for all the 4th graders in The Monticello School District. The focus was on The Native Americans culture. One of the components was having the students take part in an expert blog. They were able to correspond with a Native American expert who was Debbie. She took the time to respond to every student’s question. She made the whole unit come to life with her authentic communications. Students really came away with a real understanding of the lives and customs of Native Americans. This was one of the highlights of their educational experience that year. Debbie will always be remembered for this.
Dennis Rowen
Professor of Education.

Dennis Rowen said...

I just wanted to reminisce about Debbie from years ago. I designed an integrated literacy + content + technology unit for all the 4th graders in The Monticello School District. The focus was on The Native Americans culture. One of the components was having the students take part in an expert blog. They were able to correspond with a Native American expert who was Debbie. She took the time to respond to every student’s question. She made the whole unit come to life with her authentic communications. Students really came away with a real understanding of the lives and customs of Native Americans. This was one of the highlights of their educational experience that year. Debbie will always be remembered for this.
Dennis Rowen
Professor of Education.

Unknown said...

Thanks for doing this! I shared out with local teachers as an added resource.

Much appreciated,
Matthew

Camille said...

Thank you for this. I am a California 5th grade teacher (raised in NM), and because I am tasked with teaching US history, I feel a tremendous responsibility to not only tell the truth, but to change the way our schools have depicted Native people. I will share your recommendations with my staff and gave already shared screenshots in social media.

May I ask a question? Recently, I asked our librarian for specific titles to read before Thanksgiving in effort to tell the true story -- or at least the truest we know about. Our school library did not have them all, but I was given substitutes like Joseph Bruchac's Squanto's Journey." I reviewed it before reading it to my kids. Alarm bells went off, which brought me here. (I was already familiar with you and your work through Instagram and Pinterest, but did not know about this site.)

My question is this: What do we do with these books? Do we take them out of circulation? Is that censorship? Do I rebel and attach a note to the inside cover for future readers to find? What about the rest of the books that feature and/or inaccurately and stereotypically depict Native Americans and Native American history in our school library? I'd love to know what you recommend.

Debbie Reese said...

Camille,

We expect teachers to provide children with facts. Most of the books about Thanksgiving are not accurate. So, I would not use them. It would probably be wise for you to develop a document about the inaccurate representations of Thanksgiving and then use that as a tool to remove books. That sort of document could be part of your Collection Development policy. Look at CREW: A Weeding Manual for Modern Libraries. It has several terrific sections that you can adapt into yours.
https://www.tsl.texas.gov/sites/default/files/public/tslac/ld/ld/pubs/crew/crewmethod12.pdf